Survivor: Micronesia - Post-Season Castaway Grades - Page 2

mattaus · 05-16-2008, 04:40 AM

I mostly agree with your rankings. Cirie played a great game. What I would be interested to know is what they changed when Kathleen,James and Penner left the game. Was a final 2 always planned or did they add the extra immunity challenge to fill up the 39 days. Was the original plan for a few more days? Also, it seems kind of odd that they would have an even number of jurors. What would have happened in the event of a tie?

bynjrotc · 05-16-2008, 05:34 AM

acemondo, ONE person's vote didn't deny the idol. Amanda should have won easily over Parvoti. Obviously there were issues between players that we didn't see/were edited out. And whether you like her or not, Cirie WAS an A player. Go back & watch the episodes again - she manipulated everyone, & wasn't the only one who had bitter feelings toward Amanda. I like Amanda too, but SHE DIDN'T WIN, so get over it. As for your FAT comments - why don't you put YOUR real photo beside your comments?

bynjrotc · 05-16-2008, 05:36 AM

acemondo, ONE person's vote didn't deny the idol. Amanda should have won easily over Parvoti. Obviously there were issues between players that we didn't see/were edited out. And whether you like her or not, Cirie WAS an A player. Go back & watch the episodes again - she manipulated everyone, & wasn't the only one who had bitter feelings toward Amanda. I like Amanda too, but SHE DIDN'T WIN, so get over it. As for your FAT comments - why don't you put YOUR real photo beside your comments?

bynjrotc · 05-16-2008, 05:38 AM

acemondo, ONE person's vote didn't deny the idol. Amanda should have won easily over Parvoti. Obviously there were issues between players that we didn't see/were edited out. And whether you like her or not, Cirie WAS an A player. Go back & watch the episodes again - she manipulated everyone, & wasn't the only one who had bitter feelings toward Amanda. I like Amanda too, but SHE DIDN'T WIN, so get over it. As for your FAT comments - why don't you put YOUR real photo beside your comments?

bynjrotc · 05-16-2008, 05:41 AM

acemondo, ONE person's vote didn't deny the idol. Amanda should have won easily over Parvoti. Obviously there were issues between players that we didn't see/were edited out. And whether you like her or not, Cirie WAS an A player. Go back & watch the episodes again - she manipulated everyone, & wasn't the only one who had bitter feelings toward Amanda. I like Amanda too, but SHE DIDN'T WIN, so get over it. As for your FAT comments - why don't you put YOUR real photo beside your comments?

bynjrotc · 05-16-2008, 05:43 AM

acemondo, ONE person's vote didn't deny the idol. Amanda should have won easily over Parvoti. Obviously there were issues between players that we didn't see/were edited out. And whether you like her or not, Cirie WAS an A player. Go back & watch the episodes again - she manipulated everyone, & wasn't the only one who had bitter feelings toward Amanda. I like Amanda too, but SHE DIDN'T WIN, so get over it. As for your FAT comments - why don't you put YOUR real photo beside your comments?

bynjrotc · 05-16-2008, 05:45 AM

acemondo, ONE person's vote didn't deny the idol. Amanda should have won easily over Parvoti. Obviously there were issues between players that we didn't see/were edited out. And whether you like her or not, Cirie WAS an A player. Go back & watch the episodes again - she manipulated everyone, & wasn't the only one who had bitter feelings toward Amanda. I like Amanda too, but SHE DIDN'T WIN, so get over it. As for your FAT comments - why don't you put YOUR real photo beside your comments?

bynjrotc · 05-16-2008, 05:47 AM

acemondo, ONE person's vote didn't deny the idol. Amanda should have won easily over Parvoti. Obviously there were issues between players that we didn't see/were edited out. And whether you like her or not, Cirie WAS an A player. Go back & watch the episodes again - she manipulated everyone, & wasn't the only one who had bitter feelings toward Amanda. I like Amanda too, but SHE DIDN'T WIN, so get over it. As for your FAT comments - why don't you put YOUR real photo beside your comments?

samabbr · 05-16-2008, 06:36 AM

I agree with you top 3, Cirie, Parv and Amanda played everyone easily, and am I the only one who thinks it was fair Parvati's victory over Amanda? Cuz she and Cirie pulled Ozzy's eviction, and also Parv was the responsible for the creation of the first female alliance to really work together. She did more important things than Amanda, the only thing she did that Parvati didn't was to play the idol at the right time.

kaycee · 05-16-2008, 02:07 PM

I think I agree I think all of these. stupid Kathleen and Chet. what kind of fans were they?

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

05-16-2008, 04:40 AM	#11
mattaus Junior Member Join Date: Oct 2006 Posts: 5	I mostly agree with your rankings. Cirie played a great game. What I would be interested to know is what they changed when Kathleen,James and Penner left the game. Was a final 2 always planned or did they add the extra immunity challenge to fill up the 39 days. Was the original plan for a few more days? Also, it seems kind of odd that they would have an even number of jurors. What would have happened in the event of a tie?

05-16-2008, 05:34 AM	#12
bynjrotc Junior Member Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 23	acemondo, ONE person's vote didn't deny the idol. Amanda should have won easily over Parvoti. Obviously there were issues between players that we didn't see/were edited out. And whether you like her or not, Cirie WAS an A player. Go back & watch the episodes again - she manipulated everyone, & wasn't the only one who had bitter feelings toward Amanda. I like Amanda too, but SHE DIDN'T WIN, so get over it. As for your FAT comments - why don't you put YOUR real photo beside your comments?

05-16-2008, 05:36 AM	#13
bynjrotc Junior Member Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 23	acemondo, ONE person's vote didn't deny the idol. Amanda should have won easily over Parvoti. Obviously there were issues between players that we didn't see/were edited out. And whether you like her or not, Cirie WAS an A player. Go back & watch the episodes again - she manipulated everyone, & wasn't the only one who had bitter feelings toward Amanda. I like Amanda too, but SHE DIDN'T WIN, so get over it. As for your FAT comments - why don't you put YOUR real photo beside your comments?

05-16-2008, 05:38 AM	#14
bynjrotc Junior Member Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 23	acemondo, ONE person's vote didn't deny the idol. Amanda should have won easily over Parvoti. Obviously there were issues between players that we didn't see/were edited out. And whether you like her or not, Cirie WAS an A player. Go back & watch the episodes again - she manipulated everyone, & wasn't the only one who had bitter feelings toward Amanda. I like Amanda too, but SHE DIDN'T WIN, so get over it. As for your FAT comments - why don't you put YOUR real photo beside your comments?

05-16-2008, 05:41 AM	#15
bynjrotc Junior Member Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 23	acemondo, ONE person's vote didn't deny the idol. Amanda should have won easily over Parvoti. Obviously there were issues between players that we didn't see/were edited out. And whether you like her or not, Cirie WAS an A player. Go back & watch the episodes again - she manipulated everyone, & wasn't the only one who had bitter feelings toward Amanda. I like Amanda too, but SHE DIDN'T WIN, so get over it. As for your FAT comments - why don't you put YOUR real photo beside your comments?

05-16-2008, 05:43 AM	#16
bynjrotc Junior Member Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 23	acemondo, ONE person's vote didn't deny the idol. Amanda should have won easily over Parvoti. Obviously there were issues between players that we didn't see/were edited out. And whether you like her or not, Cirie WAS an A player. Go back & watch the episodes again - she manipulated everyone, & wasn't the only one who had bitter feelings toward Amanda. I like Amanda too, but SHE DIDN'T WIN, so get over it. As for your FAT comments - why don't you put YOUR real photo beside your comments?

05-16-2008, 05:45 AM	#17
bynjrotc Junior Member Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 23	acemondo, ONE person's vote didn't deny the idol. Amanda should have won easily over Parvoti. Obviously there were issues between players that we didn't see/were edited out. And whether you like her or not, Cirie WAS an A player. Go back & watch the episodes again - she manipulated everyone, & wasn't the only one who had bitter feelings toward Amanda. I like Amanda too, but SHE DIDN'T WIN, so get over it. As for your FAT comments - why don't you put YOUR real photo beside your comments?

05-16-2008, 05:47 AM	#18
bynjrotc Junior Member Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 23	acemondo, ONE person's vote didn't deny the idol. Amanda should have won easily over Parvoti. Obviously there were issues between players that we didn't see/were edited out. And whether you like her or not, Cirie WAS an A player. Go back & watch the episodes again - she manipulated everyone, & wasn't the only one who had bitter feelings toward Amanda. I like Amanda too, but SHE DIDN'T WIN, so get over it. As for your FAT comments - why don't you put YOUR real photo beside your comments?

05-16-2008, 06:36 AM	#19
samabbr Junior Member Join Date: Jul 2007 Posts: 15	I agree with you top 3, Cirie, Parv and Amanda played everyone easily, and am I the only one who thinks it was fair Parvati's victory over Amanda? Cuz she and Cirie pulled Ozzy's eviction, and also Parv was the responsible for the creation of the first female alliance to really work together. She did more important things than Amanda, the only thing she did that Parvati didn't was to play the idol at the right time.

05-16-2008, 02:07 PM	#20
kaycee Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: , , . Posts: 374	I think I agree I think all of these. stupid Kathleen and Chet. what kind of fans were they?