One Tree Hill: File Those Divorce Papers

buddytv · 03-06-2008, 11:45 PM

One of the interesting things about watching One Tree Hill is seeing how the relationships between the characters have changed over the years. It's hard to believe that Nathan once dated Peyton before moving on to Haley, or that Lucas (Chad Michael Murray) and Brooke (Sophia Bush) once had a thing for each other. We're so used to Nathan and Haley being married and Lucas and Peyton being on again, off again that it's strange to look back to the beginning. Now, after the latest episode, the marriage between Nathan and Haley may finally be coming to an end, while Lucas is trying to move on from Peyton and settle down with Lindsey. The question is, should either of these couples be together, or is time for One Tree Hill to shake things up?

To read the rest, click here.

erena · 03-07-2008, 08:24 AM

I don't really expect any dramatic changes. Maybe just for awhile, but then will come "...and lived happily ever after...". I don't believe that one insine nany, will cause any permanent consequences. Nathan and Haley went through so much..

justcuzifeltlikechangingthis · 03-07-2008, 08:34 AM

yeah and really that kiss was harmless, she kissed Chris Keller so she should be able to forgive him. But after reading this you made me see how interesting it could be if they split up for a little bit, not for good though

adiafaith · 03-07-2008, 09:22 AM

I don't feel like it's just the situation with the nanny that made Haley say she wanted to get divorced. I mean, for the past few months after his accident Nathan's been a poor husband and father. He got caught up in his own feelings and self-pity rather than taking into consideration that his wife (who was basically taking care of him, his child, and their home) and his son needed him more than he thought he needed basketball. And then, after those months of non-communication between them, Nathan again decides to not let Haley in on the flirtations and sexual advances this nanny has made towards him. It's like enough is enough, man. I can definitely see why Haley's ready to walk away.

I personally don't want to see them get divorced and re-married again because I really think 2 Nathan/Haley nuptials is more than enough for this series. But a temporary separation might be interesting to see...though I'm not sure if my heart can take it.

As for the other couple, I'm all for them moving on 'cause the whole Lucas/Peyton thing is like beating a dead horse. Let him marry Lindsay and live in misery, knowing that he's stuck with his second choice. It'll be great material for his next novel.

prinsesa8 · 03-07-2008, 09:25 AM

I think the idea of Lucas and Lindsey getting married would be good, they stay married for awhile and then after sometime realize it was a mistake to get married since Peyton would always be on Lucas' mind. But with Nathan and Haley, I think it would be weird to have them split up now and be separated for sometime. They have been thru a lot more than this "Carrie" problem, so hopefully I'd want them to work thru it and probably face more problems but together. I think that's a nice addition to the story since all the others are single. It would be refreshing to see a couple go thru the trials that life brings. I think alot of viewers would be able to relate to them... I know I do.

knightracer · 03-07-2008, 10:35 AM

Didn't Haley and Nathan already get remarried?

bluegins · 03-07-2008, 10:43 AM

Lucas and Lindsey SHOULD NOT get married. IT's obvious Lucas still loves Peyton and gosh his proposal sounded so fake (then maybe it's the acting =p).

And Nathan and Haley SHOULD NOT get divorced. They are perfect for each other. I love them. Obviously both of them have been pretty stupid recently but I think they'll fix it. I wish Haley could realize Nathan was perfectly faithful to her and I wish Nathan could just be honest with Haley!!!!

Also I find it just a tiny little bit hypocritical for Haley to divorce Nathan because he kissed the nanny (even though he didn't really kiss the nanny) when I clearly remember she kissed Chris and that was intentional!!! arghhh

adiafaith · 03-07-2008, 10:54 AM

Haley didn't intentionally kiss Chris. She was at the studio to let Chris know she wouldn't be seeing him anymore and when she hugged him, he kissed her. She didn't plan that. Plus, I can forgive her mistake a lot quicker 'cause she was like 16 or 17 at the time, just married, and extremely confused by everything with the music/tour and all.

In terms of divorce, if Nathan and Haley still love each other, which they clearly do, I'd have issues with them get divorced because there's a child involved as well. I'd rather see them try to work things out, even if they must separate for a bit.

hikinggirl70 · 03-07-2008, 11:18 AM

I hope Lucas doesn't marry Lindsey since he obvious still loves Peyton. I don't want Peyton to ruin the wedding because we have seen that too many times in other shows. As for Nathan and Haley, they love each other but maybe some time apart would do some good. Don't want them to get a divorce though.

AlexMack · 03-07-2008, 12:41 PM

Acutally I think I agree with the article ... a little bit of something diffrent may be what the show needs.. To me the shows lacking a lot this season and I don't know how they could possibly make it any better. I mean we all want to see happy people in good relationships but it gets so boring and played out after a while.. This season of One Tree Hill seems like one big cliche to me.. Don't get me wrong I love the show and watched it from the very beginning but somehting has to be changed. New story lines need to be written and the old ones need to be throw out.. Recylcing old story lines is all they have left about right now.. Spice it up and break things up to see how well it goes a little bit of tention from the viewers can't be so bad..

03-07-2008, 09:22 AM	#4
adiafaith Jared's S&M gal Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Brooklyn!!!! Posts: 11,956	I don't feel like it's just the situation with the nanny that made Haley say she wanted to get divorced. I mean, for the past few months after his accident Nathan's been a poor husband and father. He got caught up in his own feelings and self-pity rather than taking into consideration that his wife (who was basically taking care of him, his child, and their home) and his son needed him more than he thought he needed basketball. And then, after those months of non-communication between them, Nathan again decides to not let Haley in on the flirtations and sexual advances this nanny has made towards him. It's like enough is enough, man. I can definitely see why Haley's ready to walk away. I personally don't want to see them get divorced and re-married again because I really think 2 Nathan/Haley nuptials is more than enough for this series. But a temporary separation might be interesting to see...though I'm not sure if my heart can take it. As for the other couple, I'm all for them moving on 'cause the whole Lucas/Peyton thing is like beating a dead horse. Let him marry Lindsay and live in misery, knowing that he's stuck with his second choice. It'll be great material for his next novel. __________________ *There's a new Pretty in town and them other boys don't know how to act* AND WHEN HE NEEDS A TOWEL, ADIA'S TONGUE IS AVAILABLE Thanks to MEI for my scrumptuous sig

03-07-2008, 10:54 AM	#8
adiafaith Jared's S&M gal Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Brooklyn!!!! Posts: 11,956	Haley didn't intentionally kiss Chris. She was at the studio to let Chris know she wouldn't be seeing him anymore and when she hugged him, he kissed her. She didn't plan that. Plus, I can forgive her mistake a lot quicker 'cause she was like 16 or 17 at the time, just married, and extremely confused by everything with the music/tour and all. In terms of divorce, if Nathan and Haley still love each other, which they clearly do, I'd have issues with them get divorced because there's a child involved as well. I'd rather see them try to work things out, even if they must separate for a bit. __________________ *There's a new Pretty in town and them other boys don't know how to act* AND WHEN HE NEEDS A TOWEL, ADIA'S TONGUE IS AVAILABLE Thanks to MEI for my scrumptuous sig

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

03-06-2008, 11:45 PM	#1
buddytv Administrator Join Date: Feb 2006 Posts: 11,778,727	One of the interesting things about watching One Tree Hill is seeing how the relationships between the characters have changed over the years. It's hard to believe that Nathan once dated Peyton before moving on to Haley, or that Lucas (Chad Michael Murray) and Brooke (Sophia Bush) once had a thing for each other. We're so used to Nathan and Haley being married and Lucas and Peyton being on again, off again that it's strange to look back to the beginning. Now, after the latest episode, the marriage between Nathan and Haley may finally be coming to an end, while Lucas is trying to move on from Peyton and settle down with Lindsey. The question is, should either of these couples be together, or is time for One Tree Hill to shake things up? To read the rest, click here.

03-07-2008, 08:24 AM	#2
erena Member Join Date: May 2007 Posts: 36	I don't really expect any dramatic changes. Maybe just for awhile, but then will come "...and lived happily ever after...". I don't believe that one insine nany, will cause any permanent consequences. Nathan and Haley went through so much..

03-07-2008, 08:34 AM	#3
justcuzifeltlikechangingthis Junior Member Join Date: Jul 2007 Posts: 97	yeah and really that kiss was harmless, she kissed Chris Keller so she should be able to forgive him. But after reading this you made me see how interesting it could be if they split up for a little bit, not for good though

03-07-2008, 09:25 AM	#5
prinsesa8 Junior Member Join Date: Mar 2008 Posts: 1	I think the idea of Lucas and Lindsey getting married would be good, they stay married for awhile and then after sometime realize it was a mistake to get married since Peyton would always be on Lucas' mind. But with Nathan and Haley, I think it would be weird to have them split up now and be separated for sometime. They have been thru a lot more than this "Carrie" problem, so hopefully I'd want them to work thru it and probably face more problems but together. I think that's a nice addition to the story since all the others are single. It would be refreshing to see a couple go thru the trials that life brings. I think alot of viewers would be able to relate to them... I know I do.

03-07-2008, 10:35 AM	#6
knightracer Junior Member Join Date: Jun 2007 Posts: 4	Didn't Haley and Nathan already get remarried?

03-07-2008, 10:43 AM	#7
bluegins Junior Member Join Date: Nov 2007 Posts: 35	Lucas and Lindsey SHOULD NOT get married. IT's obvious Lucas still loves Peyton and gosh his proposal sounded so fake (then maybe it's the acting =p). And Nathan and Haley SHOULD NOT get divorced. They are perfect for each other. I love them. Obviously both of them have been pretty stupid recently but I think they'll fix it. I wish Haley could realize Nathan was perfectly faithful to her and I wish Nathan could just be honest with Haley!!!! Also I find it just a tiny little bit hypocritical for Haley to divorce Nathan because he kissed the nanny (even though he didn't really kiss the nanny) when I clearly remember she kissed Chris and that was intentional!!! arghhh

03-07-2008, 11:18 AM	#9
hikinggirl70 Senior Member Join Date: Feb 2008 Location: Farmingdale, NY Posts: 535	I hope Lucas doesn't marry Lindsey since he obvious still loves Peyton. I don't want Peyton to ruin the wedding because we have seen that too many times in other shows. As for Nathan and Haley, they love each other but maybe some time apart would do some good. Don't want them to get a divorce though.

03-07-2008, 12:41 PM	#10
AlexMack Junior Member Join Date: Apr 2007 Posts: 113	Acutally I think I agree with the article ... a little bit of something diffrent may be what the show needs.. To me the shows lacking a lot this season and I don't know how they could possibly make it any better. I mean we all want to see happy people in good relationships but it gets so boring and played out after a while.. This season of One Tree Hill seems like one big cliche to me.. Don't get me wrong I love the show and watched it from the very beginning but somehting has to be changed. New story lines need to be written and the old ones need to be throw out.. Recylcing old story lines is all they have left about right now.. Spice it up and break things up to see how well it goes a little bit of tention from the viewers can't be so bad..