One Tree Hill: A Painful Proposal

[clairelovesOTH]

as much as i hate to admit it, i agree with alexmack. ive never thought about it, but that is true. im hoping for excitement soon. and about peyton/lucas, to me, peyton came off selfish to want lucas to drop his whole life as soon as she came back to town. I was glad to see her tell him shell let go. dont get me wrong thouhg, i do want her and lucas to be together. And id hate it if carrie gets in the way of nathan and haleigh. we;ve seen them go throuhg so much throughoutt the show, im rooting for them to stay together. and by the way, im new at this, can anyone tell me what the points are?

[adiafaith]

Gotta be honest...I love OTH and all but the Lucas/Peyton storyline has dragged out for so long and has consisted of so much indecision (on both of their parts) in terms of being together that by now I've kinda stopped caring. I don't think one is more to blame than the other...they both seem to have problems fully communicating their feelings and, I hate to say it, but I don't feel like they really truly fight to be together. They just give up so easily.
Me, I'm more concerned over Nathan and Haley. That's the only couple on OTH that I'm truly invested in and concerned about. And yeah, the nanny Carrie story is just Rachel The Sequel: Crazy to the Infinite Power.

[SomethingToBe]

Lucas wanted to be Naley at 19. Thats not realistic, and Peyton was completely right to turn him down.

[hanajk]

I hate the fact that Lucas proposed to Lindsey just after he kissed Peyton... this episode made me cried a lot... sob....sob... pity Peyton...

[jedobeanbaby]

Peyton messed up and so did lucas i think that they need to end up together im glad Peyton is willing to be a friend and let go but they have been like this since season one.. I hope Carie don't break up Naley and that Nathan should of told Haley about the kiss.. I really want to see Lucas's little sister she should be like 4 now i think!!

[onetreehillaussiegal]

Peyton messed up - Lucas isn't a saint but he always said he wanted her.. and she always made him run after her. She never let him in and always had her own issues. If it were me i would get sick and tired of her games as well. Why should he have to wait and do things her way all the time? She could have come and found him after everything went down, but she waited years to try and get back with him - how long should the guy have had to wait? I'm sorry, but I'm SO over Peyton it's not funny. I liked her much better when she was with Jake.

[meika]

this episode wuz very interesteing......i like peyton and lindsay very much but i believe that lucas belongs with brooke.....

[redwinegreen]

i think that she's falling apart and wanting to drag everyone down with her.Sorry if anyone thinks thats harsh

[res262]

it was quite painful to watch the whole thing, but i would say that both parties messed, because Peyton turned down the guy, though she said, someday, but sometimes, when you want yes/no, someday just doesnt do. after all Lucas wasnt suppose to Ask Lindsey to marry him when he knew very well that his heart was conflicted. i felt sorry for the guy on the wedding day, but i guess someone has to live with consequences of thier actions, I would love them to be together, but i just hope no broke comes back into picture or something like that,

[twilight12]

Originally Posted by hanajk

I hate the fact that Lucas proposed to Lindsey just after he kissed Peyton... this episode made me cried a lot... sob....sob... pity Peyton...

I was thinking, What if Lucas didn`t mean to propose to Lindsay but she find the ring and he just have to say it was for her, because he didn`t want Lindsay to know that is was Peyton`s ring?? :O !!!!