Lost: Death Odds, and a Spoiler - Page 2

Moparlarry · 05-06-2008, 05:39 PM

All good points, but we've seen the Lost creators take the "easy" way out with Rosseau, in kind of a "you have got us figured out yet" vibe. But Claires death was forshadowed in a bigggggg way last week when she wakes up and finds Christian Sheppard holding Aaron. Her reaction is the hate/disgist we saw in the season three flash back. Instead she calls him "dad" like she's been doing it all her life. My theroy is that Christian shows up in th future to tell Jack that Claire is his hlf sister and that Aaron is is blood relative. Bernard is one step above being a red shirt, it won't be a major shock to viewers if he takes the dirt nap.
Jin? I could see him doing somehting heroic to get Sun and his unborn child off the island, we've already seen he's not above using his old tricks.
Sawyer and Locke? No way. They are too much of major players, even though sawyers role has been a little dimished as of late.

Moparlarry · 05-06-2008, 05:41 PM

Opps! what I meant to say was we didn't see Claire address Christian with the same hate/disgust as she did in the season three flashback. Shouldn't type and eat at the same time. Don't want to see her go cause that island is turning into a sausage party fast!

Talontbo · 05-06-2008, 06:21 PM

I am not buying any theory the think the Horse is Dead... clearly it is not... even Sawyer saw the Horse.. we have a Cow... we have Boar.. and Polar Bear. and any number of SeaBird.... during Migration of course...

Claire killed in the RPG to the little sweet house... One would think so... however... Sawyer Picks her up... Hurley grasp her through the window... Everyone there talks to her... Miles had Zero Reaction when she first came through the window... Dead?? Don;t Think So... And let us not forget... Jack has seen Christian.. His Daddy.. do we also think Jack is dead??? I don't...

Could Claire die however?? I do not think so... Crazy Australian psychic would have us think otherwise... Claire Dead... I sure hope not..

Michael... I vote for this Schmuck... Libby.. Ana... I would do it myself... where is he???

Evil Penny.. not listed above.. hmmm wonder why??? even after we get Bens declaration to Kill Widmore Daughter... seems safe to at least consider her.. though not a main character.. at minimum.. a hugely loved and vital one.. I would also vote for her to get the ax... 41 of them...

Locke.. highly doubtful.. but.... Locke could easily take one for the cause... Sawyer has threatened to kill Locke if one culry hair on Hurley's head is harmed... Locke could be between a rock and a hard place... Ben has seen his dead mom.. Hurley and Locke have also seen Jacob... Ben has already tried to kill Locke for hearing 'Help Me".. Ben gets two for the price of one??? and off they go to see Jacob... Just what the Benny ordered... "He seems to get what he want"... Locke, killed by Ben.. protecting Hurley... I like this even more then offing Evil Penny....

Juliette... trader... that has to make Ben super happy... she looks like Mommy... Dead Like Mommy....

Jin.. no... he makes it... gets Sun off the Island.. a clear sacrifice... the Island has to see that he is changed... don't do it....

Rose or Bernard??? I don't see it.. but Bernard is older.. the stress has to be getting to him... Rose would be the shocker... what could possibly be a better twist.. kill the second sweetist character on the Island...

whoever it is... I am sure... someone is not gonna be happy... and the rest of us are...LOL

TaylorJohnston3 · 05-06-2008, 07:51 PM

Why would Claire be hopping onto a helicopter with baby Aaron (which Desmond flashed) iif she's dead / a ghost?

Blakeney · 05-06-2008, 08:05 PM

One thing I don't get - Miles never registered Claire's Dad as a ghost.

LeLost · 05-06-2008, 10:59 PM

Few months ago, rumour was that Claire was definitely on a chopper with baby Aaron but was pushed and fell down into the ocean.

LeLost · 05-06-2008, 11:03 PM

I meant that, few months ago, rumour was that Claire WILL definitely BE on a chopper with baby Aaron but WILL be pushed and WILL fall down into the ocean.

Spera · 05-07-2008, 12:16 AM

Clairs not dead or dying-- she "has to be the one to raise her child" just like hurly was teleling jack from charlie- no one's supposed to raise the bay-bay but claire. You don't kill off the madonna of the series.

I think michael will kick it. And I'll be glad to see him go-- and it will be a reason for walt to come back since i don't think his story is over.

80sPro · 05-07-2008, 05:23 AM

I maintain that she will be reunited with Aaron at the end of the series, which will break Kate's heart of course. But I can't allow that she would actually die. That said, we all seem to feel the same way - and Darlton like that. They WANT us to be emotionally involved. So.....I hate to say it, and as much as I want all the prophecy to be true (no one else must raise this child; Desmond seeing her and Aaron on a chopper; forging a relationship with her brother) I just think it's a done deal. Maybe she WILL fall off the chopper, or be shot from the ground by a Freighter Folk.I am sad today - but I think it's perfect, because now Jack has to work his feelings out so he can raise his nephew with Kate. If he ends up with Kate....argh! Too much to ponder! Just kill Michael off already and let Claire live!!!

Khrixtina · 05-07-2008, 05:25 AM

Claire can't die...In season one we saw that claire has to raise his baby or a bad thing will happen to the baby and only her can protect him...

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

05-06-2008, 05:39 PM	#11
Moparlarry Junior Member Join Date: Mar 2007 Posts: 11	All good points, but we've seen the Lost creators take the "easy" way out with Rosseau, in kind of a "you have got us figured out yet" vibe. But Claires death was forshadowed in a bigggggg way last week when she wakes up and finds Christian Sheppard holding Aaron. Her reaction is the hate/disgist we saw in the season three flash back. Instead she calls him "dad" like she's been doing it all her life. My theroy is that Christian shows up in th future to tell Jack that Claire is his hlf sister and that Aaron is is blood relative. Bernard is one step above being a red shirt, it won't be a major shock to viewers if he takes the dirt nap. Jin? I could see him doing somehting heroic to get Sun and his unborn child off the island, we've already seen he's not above using his old tricks. Sawyer and Locke? No way. They are too much of major players, even though sawyers role has been a little dimished as of late.

05-06-2008, 05:41 PM	#12
Moparlarry Junior Member Join Date: Mar 2007 Posts: 11	Opps! what I meant to say was we didn't see Claire address Christian with the same hate/disgust as she did in the season three flashback. Shouldn't type and eat at the same time. Don't want to see her go cause that island is turning into a sausage party fast!

05-06-2008, 06:21 PM	#13
Talontbo Senior Member Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 529	I am not buying any theory the think the Horse is Dead... clearly it is not... even Sawyer saw the Horse.. we have a Cow... we have Boar.. and Polar Bear. and any number of SeaBird.... during Migration of course... Claire killed in the RPG to the little sweet house... One would think so... however... Sawyer Picks her up... Hurley grasp her through the window... Everyone there talks to her... Miles had Zero Reaction when she first came through the window... Dead?? Don;t Think So... And let us not forget... Jack has seen Christian.. His Daddy.. do we also think Jack is dead??? I don't... Could Claire die however?? I do not think so... Crazy Australian psychic would have us think otherwise... Claire Dead... I sure hope not.. Michael... I vote for this Schmuck... Libby.. Ana... I would do it myself... where is he??? Evil Penny.. not listed above.. hmmm wonder why??? even after we get Bens declaration to Kill Widmore Daughter... seems safe to at least consider her.. though not a main character.. at minimum.. a hugely loved and vital one.. I would also vote for her to get the ax... 41 of them... Locke.. highly doubtful.. but.... Locke could easily take one for the cause... Sawyer has threatened to kill Locke if one culry hair on Hurley's head is harmed... Locke could be between a rock and a hard place... Ben has seen his dead mom.. Hurley and Locke have also seen Jacob... Ben has already tried to kill Locke for hearing 'Help Me".. Ben gets two for the price of one??? and off they go to see Jacob... Just what the Benny ordered... "He seems to get what he want"... Locke, killed by Ben.. protecting Hurley... I like this even more then offing Evil Penny.... Juliette... trader... that has to make Ben super happy... she looks like Mommy... Dead Like Mommy.... Jin.. no... he makes it... gets Sun off the Island.. a clear sacrifice... the Island has to see that he is changed... don't do it.... Rose or Bernard??? I don't see it.. but Bernard is older.. the stress has to be getting to him... Rose would be the shocker... what could possibly be a better twist.. kill the second sweetist character on the Island... whoever it is... I am sure... someone is not gonna be happy... and the rest of us are...LOL

05-06-2008, 07:51 PM	#14
TaylorJohnston3 Junior Member Join Date: May 2008 Posts: 2	Why would Claire be hopping onto a helicopter with baby Aaron (which Desmond flashed) iif she's dead / a ghost?

05-06-2008, 08:05 PM	#15
Blakeney Junior Member Join Date: Jan 2008 Posts: 50	One thing I don't get - Miles never registered Claire's Dad as a ghost.

05-06-2008, 10:59 PM	#16
LeLost Junior Member Join Date: Mar 2008 Posts: 6	Few months ago, rumour was that Claire was definitely on a chopper with baby Aaron but was pushed and fell down into the ocean.

05-06-2008, 11:03 PM	#17
LeLost Junior Member Join Date: Mar 2008 Posts: 6	I meant that, few months ago, rumour was that Claire WILL definitely BE on a chopper with baby Aaron but WILL be pushed and WILL fall down into the ocean.

05-07-2008, 12:16 AM	#18
Spera Junior Member Join Date: Jun 2007 Posts: 5	Clairs not dead or dying-- she "has to be the one to raise her child" just like hurly was teleling jack from charlie- no one's supposed to raise the bay-bay but claire. You don't kill off the madonna of the series. I think michael will kick it. And I'll be glad to see him go-- and it will be a reason for walt to come back since i don't think his story is over.

05-07-2008, 05:23 AM	#19
80sPro Junior Member Join Date: May 2007 Posts: 247	I maintain that she will be reunited with Aaron at the end of the series, which will break Kate's heart of course. But I can't allow that she would actually die. That said, we all seem to feel the same way - and Darlton like that. They WANT us to be emotionally involved. So.....I hate to say it, and as much as I want all the prophecy to be true (no one else must raise this child; Desmond seeing her and Aaron on a chopper; forging a relationship with her brother) I just think it's a done deal. Maybe she WILL fall off the chopper, or be shot from the ground by a Freighter Folk.I am sad today - but I think it's perfect, because now Jack has to work his feelings out so he can raise his nephew with Kate. If he ends up with Kate....argh! Too much to ponder! Just kill Michael off already and let Claire live!!!

05-07-2008, 05:25 AM	#20
Khrixtina Junior Member Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 29	Claire can't die...In season one we saw that claire has to raise his baby or a bad thing will happen to the baby and only her can protect him...