Round 24: Man O'Faith vs. Man O'Science

So throughout this season, the question has been does everything in life boil down to faith or down to science?

Jack says science. John said faith until he saw the videos and then he said science too. Until he realized he messed up big time and the one thing he had been pursuing and believing in killed him when he questioned it...or did it? Well, I'm not too sure if he had enough time to change his vote before it was too late, but it's not too late for you!

Who do you think won this round? Man of Science or Man of Faith? (in relation to the island and the show only, please!)

[abz]

Man of faith could be Locke or Ecko at this point. I know they might both be dead , but I still think they carry a moral victory out of the finale. They were right (or Locke was until he lost faith) about the button. Jack was not only wrong about the button; his plan was not well thought out and so he is a captive.