Plot Holes, Problems, Questions and Mysteries

[Desi's Brother]

Ok, There are so many unanswered questions....

Here are some that still do not make any sense. This is going back to the first season. I really hope these things get addressed!


* How did the Dharma Initiative Find the Island?
* Who or what is Jacob?
* How did the Black Rock get to the middle of the island?
* Who is Richard? Why doesn't he age?
* Why did Naomi have a picture of Desmond and Penny?
* Why did Desmond have flashes of Charlie death?
* Why have his flashes stopped?
* Did anything come of Charlie's death? Why didn't Claire leave in a helicopter?
* What is the connection between Paik Industries, Widmore and Dharma?
* Who are Adam and Eve?
* Why do some people die on the island while others are healed?
* Why did the Monster kill Mr. Eko?
* Why was Libby in the mental hospital?
* What are the voices?
* Why did they kill Nadia?
* Why Polar Bears?
* What other times did the island move? Was that the incodent?
* What are the numbers? Why?
* Why does Abaddon send Lapidus, Charlotte, Dan and Ghostbuster?
* Why have we never heard the whole "Don't let Aaron be raised by another" thing since the second season? Isn't Kate raising Aaron in contradiction of this?
* Who is Mathew Abbadon and how does he fit in?
* Who is on what side? ----is it Jacob, Richard, Shepard------Widmore, Paik, Dharma, Abbadon------Monster? --------Mrs. Hawkins??
* Who the hell was Mrs. Hawkins?
* Why did Locke have visions? Why have they stopped?
* Are they all reinccarnated?
* How did Yemy's plane end up on the island?
* Will we ever see the medusa spider again? What was the point of that?
* What is up with Walt's Powers?
* Why was Ben leaving the island before?
* Why is Sayid killing all these people? What are they doing?
* Was Lapidus meant to be on the island?
* Does Desi have to go back to the island? If so will he lose Penny?
* Are all the people who have died not meant to be on the island?
* Why did the monster eat the pilot?--because he wasn't Lapidus?
* Who was Naomi? (I really want to know this!)
* Is Juliet chosen?
* What the hell does Cindy saying "We are here to watch" mean? (THE STUPIDEST MOMENT OF LOST EVER!!!!)
* The Universe course corrects itself??
* Will we ever get a Rousseau flashback!!???
* Will we ever see Marvin Candle in the flesh?
* What is Charlotte's connection to the island?
* What is the box?
* Why did the real "Sawyer" have to die?
* What happened to Naomi's helicopter? What crashed in to the ocean? Who was flying it?
* How was the island hidden before the hatch blew up?
* Why did the sky turn purple?
* What is with the temple and the four toed sculpture?
* Why was Claire's boyfriend's painting hanging in Widmore's office? WTF?
* How did Locke die?

My brain is going to explode!!!

[Desi's Brother]

Continuing..

* Who dropped the dharma suplies? (I really want this one answered!!)

[joko]

Adding:

* Why didn't Jack have a scar from having his appendix removed in the flashforward where he wakes up in his and Kate's house?

[mugatu22]

Originally Posted by joko

Adding:

* Why didn't Jack have a scar from having his appendix removed in the flashforward where he wakes up in his and Kate's house?

He clearly did have the scar, and this has been discussed ad infinitum. Search the forum & you'll find the screen shots. The scar is highly visible.

[sugarnuts]

okay heres one i've been thinking about for a while.
Richard Malkin ( Claire's phsycic) told her that she , and she alone, must raise the baby. it is extremely important, and catastrophic events will unfold if this doesn't happen.
Well, kate's raising Aaron and has been for a while, so why hasn't anything happened yet? or what will happen?

[Desi's Brother]

Continuing:

* Why does Naomi think that there may be survivors of Oceanic Flight 815 on the island? What would lead her to think this? Especially if the plane has been found?

* Why is the team she leads only those four and not Keamy and the other mercenaries? Is she involved with Keamy and Widmore and secretly on a mission with Abbdadon on the side? This is very confusing. I think the freighter people story needs to be expanded on way more.

* Why does the Naomi state that the scientific team has priority over everyone else? What I'm not getting is why all these people are on the boat in the first place if it is such a secret mission. Why have such a large crew of unknowns?

* Why do both Naomi and Charlotte speak so many languages? Why does Charlotte Speak Korean?

* What does "N I'll always be with you R. G." Mean??????

[Desi's Brother]

http://www.lostpedia.com/wiki/Naomi_Dorrit/Theories

I'm digging the Lostpedia Naomi theories, that she is involved in the planting of the fake airoplane. Which is why she knows about there being survivors of the plane crash even though the plane has already been descovered!!!

[rivum]

Originally Posted by sugarnuts

okay heres one i've been thinking about for a while.
Richard Malkin ( Claire's phsycic) told her that she , and she alone, must raise the baby. it is extremely important, and catastrophic events will unfold if this doesn't happen.
Well, kate's raising Aaron and has been for a while, so why hasn't anything happened yet? or what will happen?

ah, but how do we know that catastrophic events have not, in fact, unfolded?
he may not have been referring to catastrophic events happening to aaron - maybe to the rest of the world?
we already know that significant events happened on the island subsequent to them leaving, that may be it?

[lost_grrl]

Originally Posted by Desi's Brother

Continuing:

* Why does the Naomi state that the scientific team has priority over everyone else? What I'm not getting is why all these people are on the boat in the first place if it is such a secret mission. Why have such a large crew of unknowns?

* Why do both Naomi and Charlotte speak so many languages? Why does Charlotte Speak Korean?

Your question about why Naomi says that the scientific team has priority is a good one, considering the only true mission we have heard from anyone on the boat is that they are to capture Linus. Clearly scientists are not the best choice for getting someone who is hard to get. So clearly capturing Ben wasn't Chuck's only goal. He wants to learn more about the island too, probably so he can figure out a way to get back on it (as I suspect that he was kicked off the last time it was in danger and he had to move the donkey wheel).

As a rule, people outside of America are much more likely to know more languages than we do. Korean is not really high on the list of Westerners to learn---unless for a specific purpose. This was discussed on another thread. I think that Charlotte work/s/ed for Paik Industries.

More later...there are just too many questions, Brutha!

[erikau]

Originally Posted by sugarnuts

okay heres one i've been thinking about for a while.
Richard Malkin ( Claire's phsycic) told her that she , and she alone, must raise the baby. it is extremely important, and catastrophic events will unfold if this doesn't happen.
Well, kate's raising Aaron and has been for a while, so why hasn't anything happened yet? or what will happen?

As sort of a part B to your question, if Claire is supposed to raise Aaron or something terrible will happen, then how do we take Kate's dream/vision of Claire at the end of the season? If Claire needs Aaron back, why would she tell Kate to never bring him back there? Is Claire evil now? Has taking Aaron away from her somehow changed something? Or, was that some sort of nightmare caused by someone else and not really a message from Claire at all? Or, was Malkin a sort of bad guy all along, just lying to Claire to manipulate her into crashing onto the Island for some altogether unknown purpose?