Charlie's Greatest Hits

[Erin_Kelzo]

You know, Aaron not having that ring is terribly sad!

I thought Charlie wrote that in permanent marker, who knows, maybe Des will pull it out and it will have survived somehow... pulpy yeah, but legible?

[whytboyroy]

Hello all, I've been a lurker here off and on, never really posted anything useful though. Anyways, before season 4 began, I was killing time by watching the season 3 dvds and something occured to me. Naomi tells Charlie that everyone made a big deal out of it when the plane crashed and they released a Driveshaft "Greatest Hits" album. Why or how would they release a Greatest Hits album when they only had one song that anybody knew about? I'd liken it to a Vanilla Ice greatest hits cd. They would not release such an album because no one would care.

[clueless1der]

I just had a genius plot point. The Looking Glass station wasn't all the way flooded, right? SO, knowing that giving Claire Charlie's greatest hits would send legions of fangirls squeeeee-ing into the night, he leaves it in one of the lockers. Then, after making it back to the beach he goes in search of a Ziploc bag.... no... no you over there, I can see you doubting. Obviously they're located next to the tarps, aisle three at your friendly neighborhood Darhma Wal-Mart. Anyway, Desmond swims back down, ignored poor Charlie who is kinda floating around, opens up the locker, pops the paper into the baggie and swims back up to deliver it to a sobbing, but very grateful Claire.

The end.

[DarthVibbert]

and now Desmond has left the island so, so much for him honoring Charlie's last wish in giving that list to Claire

[Desi's Brother]

Yeah I'm annoyed by the lack of Sun and Jin. Come on are they just getting dumped as characters? Surely not since their story is one of the best.

Well the Desi issue has now been resolved. It was funny how the triumphant music came on when Desmond arrived---is that because he is a great character who we hadn't seen for a while?

Yeah, I hope Claire gets the list. He probably doesn't even realize he has it. He might find it while on board the freighter.

[Gartism]

Originally Posted by Erin_Kelzo

I thought Charlie wrote that in permanent marker, who knows, maybe Des will pull it out and it will have survived somehow... pulpy yeah, but legible?

Very true -- magic marker doesn't run after drying. Desmond could have given her the list after the two groups split up at the plane. Bet we get an episode where they go back and show that.

Of course, since the Producers used Hurley's Hug to completely block the fact that "Claire" couldn't act sad...maybe we'll never see that

[Addicted2TV]

Wow, I can't believe I forgot all about that sweet list! I really hope Desmond gives it to her soon. You can only imagine what kind of scene that would be.

My poor Charlie...