Charlie stuff I noticed and he is a hobbit

[TexMontana]

and my proof is in the size of his shoe!!! check it out... inside the shoes is the number 3.... small feet for a man.. but normal for a hobbit


also who is the mugger??its not charlies brother is it


Charlie was also performing on a street corner in Covet Gardens Covent Garden - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia in London.... but what is "UndercrounD" as you see in the signage in the background



last but not least.... is Charlie playing Alice and following the White Rabbit down a hole? you can see the white rabbit logo on the stations top

[Bentiss]

I thought the same thing about the mugger being Charlie's brother or one of the guys from the band...

Got a screen shot of the band sitting in the bus. That hat looks familiar...

I don't think Charlie knew about it if it was because he included it in his Greatest Hits. If it were just a ploy to get her into bed or something, he might have worded it differently...

[Bentiss]

I just rewatched the flashback of Charie and the band hearing their song on the radio for the first time. It looks EXACTLY like one of the guys in the band. Same hat. I'm surprised this hasn't been mentioned yet.

Check right after they change the radio station. The guy with the cigarette in his mouth...It was pouring rain in both scenes...Charlie looked directly at him, however. Maybe there's more to that scene than we know. The more I think about it, the more I might be wrong. Again, they look very similar, but I'm not sure if they're the same...Need more evidence...

[TexMontana]

here are the two band mates from inside the van... it does look a little like the fellow with the hat on

[Bentiss]

look at their sideburns and nose...

[DJGonzo]

I thoght that he looked familiar. Especially because the guy just ran off and didn't try to come after Charlie. I kind of assumed it was his brother.

[vickiev]

Even in the pouring rain and in the excitement of chasing off a mugger, Charlie surely would have recognized his own brother or a fellow bandmate, even if it were a number of years. IF he had, surely he would have had a different reaction, he did, after all, look the guy in the face.

IMO this mugger is not someone Charlie knew.

I think he ran away because muggers who attack women in an alley, are too spineless to go up against another man.

[TexMontana]

are we sure that DriveShaft was a band at the time charlie stopped the mugger??? if not then charlie may not have known who the fellow was

[Bentiss]

Even in the pouring rain and in the excitement of chasing off a mugger, Charlie surely would have recognized his own brother or a fellow bandmate, even if it were a number of years. IF he had, surely he would have had a different reaction, he did, after all, look the guy in the face.

That's what I thought too and this led me to believe I was just looking too hard...

are we sure that DriveShaft was a band at the time charlie stopped the mugger??? if not then charlie may not have known who the fellow was

Now this is something I didn't think of and brings credibility to what I first thought. Do we know the timeline of Charlie's band or flashbacks? The flashback with Desmond in it could have been before the band was formed. Maybe that's why he had his name on the cardboard...No one knew who he was. This was years before Charlie made it to the island. Desmond was still yet to serve in the army at this point, correct? It was after his talk with Mr. Widmore that he joined, correct? How long was he in the army? And again, how long was he on the island? Reasonably, this could have been 5 or so years before Flight 815 crashed. How long was DriveShaft a band? There's a lot of questions here that might have answers...

BRING 'EM...This needs some clearing up...

If Charlies flashback was supposed to be set in the same time frame as Desmonds flashback or whatever it was, then it would have been before Driveshaft formed I think, As you say Bentiss, Desmond visited Mr Widmore before a stint in the Army which lead to him spending some time in Jail.....this is not a definate timeline....I'm just pointing you in the right direction from what I think I know!