[SPOILERS OBVIOUSLY] Ok I hope this isn't out of place or whatever...

WhiteCheddar360 · 10-19-2009, 06:39 PM

Ok I put this under spoilers because I'm writing during "Tabula Rasa" anyways I have a myriad of questions and thougths, so yeah. Which when I start asking questions I always feel stupid because obviously the writers are taking it in a direction that will unfold but still.

First, Why didn't they use Claire's blood to save Nathan? They just said in this episode that it wouldn't be able to heal Hiro's tumor, but his wound should have been able to have been repaired.

Second, I posted this on Hulu as well under the last episode because they were talking about the whole Matt Parkman/Sylar of one mind thing, and bringing Sylar back. Well apparent from this episode, Sylar is getting his memories back, but I wondered that if Sylar's conscious is in Matt Parkman's head, then will any of his self by in his real body?

Ok, some new things. Damien who just gave Sylar his memories back, is he the antithesis of the Haitian? Are they possibly related?

Haha, Peter just tried to freeze time and got him self shot, it was a pretty awesome intense scene.

And I don't really remember the season finale, but how come Peter didn't steal Sylar's ability of being able to hold an arsenal of powers? It was his old ability and then he lost it, but that's always been Sylar's ability, or can Peter only take the ability that Sylar is using currently?

And finally, is Sue Thomas the Sue Storm of light now?? And BTW Sue Thomas is Emma. Look up Sue Thomas F.B.Eye Oh and Hiro just froze time in the hospital and froze her soundwave/light things too.

Ok the episode is over and I just saw the preview for next weeks episode. Apparently I was half right and Sylar isn't in his body, he's all in Matt Parkman, and procedes to have sex with Matt's wife. And I'm hoping that Gabriel/Nathan/Who The F*** Ever kicks that fast little carnies butt. It's funny when people get in over their heads with anger and then get pwned. Even in television.

VyncintHeart · 10-19-2009, 09:26 PM

That is a good question about Nathan.. I wondered that as well...

That haitian thing is exactly what I thought!

Sylar's base power isn't stealing powers. It's seeing how things work, so I assume that is why Peter can't take that power... OR it might be because he can only take the power currently being used.

rich1051414 · 10-19-2009, 10:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VyncintHeart

That is a good question about Nathan.. I wondered that as well...

they cant use her blood on a dead body...once your dead your dead, unless someone arises that can raise the dead, but obviously they didnt know any

Quote:

Originally Posted by VyncintHeart

And I don't really remember the season finale, but how come Peter didn't steal Sylar's ability of being able to hold an arsenal of powers? It was his old ability and then he lost it, but that's always been Sylar's ability, or can Peter only take the ability that Sylar is using currently?

peter could not control the hunger the first time, which is why his dad took his power in the first place...

Urine Engineer · 10-19-2009, 10:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WhiteCheddar360

First, Why didn't they use Claire's blood to save Nathan? They just said in this episode that it wouldn't be able to heal Hiro's tumor, but his wound should have been able to have been repaired.

1. More important question: Why didn't they use Sylar's blood?
2. Was Clair readily/relatively available?
3. Angela Petrilli dreamed that Sylar was her son and that Matt would be there at the scene of Nathan/Sylar's death. This may have influenced her decision.

Quote:

Second, I posted this on Hulu as well under the last episode because they were talking about the whole Matt Parkman/Sylar of one mind thing, and bringing Sylar back. Well apparent from this episode, Sylar is getting his memories back, but I wondered that if Sylar's conscious is in Matt Parkman's head, then will any of his self by in his real body?

It is possible that the artificial Nathan inside Sylar's body is in fact the only controlling mental entity. Sylar's memories have come back, but memories alone won't change this new person back into Sylar.

Quote:

Ok, some new things. Damien who just gave Sylar his memories back, is he the antithesis of the Haitian? Are they possibly related?

They're both black? Obviously.

Quote:

And I don't really remember the season finale, but how come Peter didn't steal Sylar's ability of being able to hold an arsenal of powers? It was his old ability and then he lost it, but that's always been Sylar's ability, or can Peter only take the ability that Sylar is using currently?

Holding multiple powers isn't a power Sylar has. Sylar has the ability to understand things. He figured out how to take powers from people's brains and insert them into his own. Sylar steals powers like stealin kidneys. Peter makes a personal copy for himself.

Peter's original power was stolen by Arthur, then he used "The Formula" to give himself a power. Peter can touch anyone and copy one power from them. He can hold one copied power at a time (so far). Usually he copies powers intentionally, but can copy a power by accident. Peter might have the same power as Arthur, but if so, he just hasn't figured out how to steal powers for himself to keep and for the victum to lose the power.

Sneaks · 10-20-2009, 01:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rich1051414

they cant use her blood on a dead body...once your dead your dead, unless someone arises that can raise the dead, but obviously they didnt know any

peter could not control the hunger the first time, which is why his dad took his power in the first place...

mohinder shot hrg through the eye and killed him, and then injected him with claire's blood to bring him back to life, sooo, they can use blood on a dead body

rich1051414 · 10-20-2009, 09:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sneaks

mohinder shot hrg through the eye and killed him, and then injected him with claire's blood to bring him back to life, sooo, they can use blood on a dead body

but was he actually dead, brain dead and dead dead are two different things, seems to make since that the heart has to be pumping...

fatj0 · 10-21-2009, 01:13 PM

I'm with rich, you can get shot through the eye and survive, you'd be messed up, but potentially still living. With the jugular vein/carotid artery slashed, he'd be dead pretty quickly. plus, if claire's blood was used then these forums would be full of "i can't believe someone was killed off only to have claire's blood used to bring him back, again." it would just be lazy writing.

Sneaks · 10-24-2009, 05:56 PM

well i just clarified that in another thread, when claire died the few times, the branch being stuck in the back of her head and so on, her eyes glazed over, and hrg's eyes were glazed over when he got shot through the eye, so its assumed that hrg was completely head when he got pumped with claires blood.

10-19-2009, 06:39 PM	#1
WhiteCheddar360 Junior Member Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 5	[SPOILERS OBVIOUSLY] Ok I hope this isn't out of place or whatever... Ok I put this under spoilers because I'm writing during "Tabula Rasa" anyways I have a myriad of questions and thougths, so yeah. Which when I start asking questions I always feel stupid because obviously the writers are taking it in a direction that will unfold but still. First, Why didn't they use Claire's blood to save Nathan? They just said in this episode that it wouldn't be able to heal Hiro's tumor, but his wound should have been able to have been repaired. Second, I posted this on Hulu as well under the last episode because they were talking about the whole Matt Parkman/Sylar of one mind thing, and bringing Sylar back. Well apparent from this episode, Sylar is getting his memories back, but I wondered that if Sylar's conscious is in Matt Parkman's head, then will any of his self by in his real body? Ok, some new things. Damien who just gave Sylar his memories back, is he the antithesis of the Haitian? Are they possibly related? Haha, Peter just tried to freeze time and got him self shot, it was a pretty awesome intense scene. And I don't really remember the season finale, but how come Peter didn't steal Sylar's ability of being able to hold an arsenal of powers? It was his old ability and then he lost it, but that's always been Sylar's ability, or can Peter only take the ability that Sylar is using currently? And finally, is Sue Thomas the Sue Storm of light now?? And BTW Sue Thomas is Emma. Look up Sue Thomas F.B.Eye Oh and Hiro just froze time in the hospital and froze her soundwave/light things too. Ok the episode is over and I just saw the preview for next weeks episode. Apparently I was half right and Sylar isn't in his body, he's all in Matt Parkman, and procedes to have sex with Matt's wife. And I'm hoping that Gabriel/Nathan/Who The F*** Ever kicks that fast little carnies butt. It's funny when people get in over their heads with anger and then get pwned. Even in television. Last edited by WhiteCheddar360 : 10-19-2009 at 07:04 PM. Reason: Added information.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

10-19-2009, 09:26 PM	#2
VyncintHeart Member Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 31	That is a good question about Nathan.. I wondered that as well... That haitian thing is exactly what I thought! Sylar's base power isn't stealing powers. It's seeing how things work, so I assume that is why Peter can't take that power... OR it might be because he can only take the power currently being used.

10-21-2009, 01:13 PM	#7
fatj0 Senior Member Join Date: Sep 2007 Posts: 430	I'm with rich, you can get shot through the eye and survive, you'd be messed up, but potentially still living. With the jugular vein/carotid artery slashed, he'd be dead pretty quickly. plus, if claire's blood was used then these forums would be full of "i can't believe someone was killed off only to have claire's blood used to bring him back, again." it would just be lazy writing.

10-24-2009, 05:56 PM	#8
Sneaks Junior Member Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 28	well i just clarified that in another thread, when claire died the few times, the branch being stuck in the back of her head and so on, her eyes glazed over, and hrg's eyes were glazed over when he got shot through the eye, so its assumed that hrg was completely head when he got pumped with claires blood.