Nathan And Claires Mom Knew

[Guest]

Ok I was just thinking about something. Maybe Nathan isn't Claire's father. Maybe it's Nathan and Peter's father that's her real father. Didn't Nathan say he always had to clean up their father's messes. That Linderman had something to hold over him and Nathan was going to expose his father because he was tired of covering thing up for him? Then the father killed himself. Maybe Nathan had gone to Claire's mother to discuss the "Claire problem" his father had, and that's when the xxxx hit the fan. Isn't Nathan kind of young to have a daughter that old?

I can't remember what her mother said when she called it was something like you may not remember me, but our daughter just found me. Wouldn't he remember the woman he had a baby with? It doesn't have to be Nathan "our" could be her and his father. She couldn't call his father could she? Maybe Nathan's father is the one that was there and flew her out. Just a thought. [/b]

That would make sense... I mean, it's a very sound theory. Good detective work.

[Guest]

I can't remember what her mother said when she called it was something like you may not remember me, but our daughter just found me. Wouldn't he remember the woman he had a baby with?[/b]

Not necessarily, it could've been an affair in which they were drunk/hazy/don't remember anything.

How many of us remember everything that happened ~16 years ago in our lives, even if we were adults and were sober (I was 7 at the time?)

I made a post a while back about how i thought Nathan and Claires mom already knew about their powers but someone thought it couldnt be possible. Claires mother just said how when she looked down and saw the roof, meaning she was in the sky, thought nobody could survive that fire. I think Merideth's power was still unstable at the time and accidentally blew up the house or something. Nathan then flew Merideth and himself away from the fire thinking Claire could no longer be alive. Since then Nathan hated his powers because "special powers" accidentally killed his daughter. Also this is why he told Peter to stop trying before he puts more people in danger.[/b]

I actually didn't think of that. Good catch!

This new revelation doesn't make much sense to be either b/c looking back at "six months ago" episode, that was supposedly Nathan discovered his ability to fly. If that's true, he couldn't have flown Meredith out of the fire.[/b]

Perhaps he couldn't control them well. He just managed from instinct to use them when he did. Not that you yourself say that's when he "supposedly" discovered his ability. That could be just what they want us to think!

There appears to be something that hasn't explained yet (or I just missed it):
Nathan + Merideth = Claire

Claire = step-daughter of HRG

HRG & Haitian try to capture Nathan, why?
Apparently, neither HRG & Nathan are aware of Claire's connections between the both of them; HRG doesn't know that Claire is Nathan's daughter, and Nathan does not know that daughter lives with HRG who also tried to capture Nathan in Vegas.[/b]

That is an interesting connection. It could be something, or it could just be the fact that HRG seems to capture different people with powers...

Ok I was just thinking about something. Maybe Nathan isn't Claire's father. Maybe it's Nathan and Peter's father that's her real father. Didn't Nathan say he always had to clean up their father's messes. That Linderman had something to hold over him and Nathan was going to expose his father because he was tired of covering thing up for him? Then the father killed himself. Maybe Nathan had gone to Claire's mother to discuss the "Claire problem" his father had, and that's when the xxxx hit the fan. Isn't Nathan kind of young to have a daughter that old?

I can't remember what her mother said when she called it was something like you may not remember me, but our daughter just found me. Wouldn't he remember the woman he had a baby with? It doesn't have to be Nathan "our" could be her and his father. She couldn't call his father could she? Maybe Nathan's father is the one that was there and flew her out. Just a thought. [/b]

I'm gonna go out and say it: I don't believe it. I think Nathan is the father.
However, I give you points for such strong research and backing for your theory. It is pretty good, and one theory I wouldn't be so surprised to see actually be the truth.
But for now, I'm believing it's Nathan.

[Guest]

I think that Nathan is the father...
his old enough to be her father.
that would explain the connection she felt with Peter and the fact that felt it too.

btw Nathan looked like he was stunned about not controlling his power in six months ago because when Peter asked him he came up with a lie pretty quickly.

I'm wondering how Claire ended up as HRG's daughter....and how this all seems normal to HRG's wife...

[Michhhy]

He probably had the Haitian erase her memory about the fire, and then decided "out of the blue" to get a daughter, even though he already picked one out (I guess you could say). But I'm pretty sure HRG knows what he's doing. He won't leave strings this important to be unraveled later.

Definetly some good theories keep it up guys i love reading em.

Ok I was just thinking about something. Maybe Nathan isn't Claire's father. Maybe it's Nathan and Peter's father that's her real father. Didn't Nathan say he always had to clean up their father's messes. That Linderman had something to hold over him and Nathan was going to expose his father because he was tired of covering thing up for him? Then the father killed himself. Maybe Nathan had gone to Claire's mother to discuss the "Claire problem" his father had, and that's when the xxxx hit the fan. Isn't Nathan kind of young to have a daughter that old?

I can't remember what her mother said when she called it was something like you may not remember me, but our daughter just found me. Wouldn't he remember the woman he had a baby with? It doesn't have to be Nathan "our" could be her and his father. She couldn't call his father could she? Maybe Nathan's father is the one that was there and flew her out. Just a thought. [/b]

I don't know thats sonds alittle off but you never know wireder things have happend.