Speculating On Major Plot Twist - Page 3

gentlefury · 11-22-2006, 10:43 AM

Quote:

Well, with your superior powers of observation and your apparently endless time to read every post, on every thread, under every topic, A ) Tell us what is going to happen; B ) Dispel any erroneous theories and C ) Become Grand Pooba of Heroes fans and declare any speculation other than your own off limits for discussion?

Geez, dude. Lighten up. This is a forum about a fictional TV series. It's no biggie.
[/b]

Nah, i'd rather just watch it and let it unravel as it will, rather than trying my hardest to come up with one theory after another thats already been said a million times.

11-22-2006, 10:48 AM

Quote:

This is a nice theory, but not plausible. Ted (radiation guy) was released to Homeland Security. Homeland security did not exist until 2002. All other timelines are current day (even close to the current time of the year). Claire and Molly are too far apart in years for this to work out.

It would be a cool thread though.

Great series, I'm addicted. B)
[/b]

Good points. Like I said, just a theory on a major plot twist. I wonder if we'll learn more about Molly Walker -- or her parents in the future. It seems that Sylar wanted more than her mother's brain.

If we caught a glimpse of the full list of "heroes" on Dr. Suresh's computer, the only name that seems to come close is Candace W_ _ _. Does anyone have the earlier episodes? Does Aubrey say the name of the woman Sylar killed when Molly was found?

Quote:

Nah, i'd rather just watch it and let it unravel as it will, rather than trying my hardest to come up with one theory after another thats already been said a million times.
[/b]

IOW, you don't have any theories of your own, so it's easier to go around carping about others who are having a good time trying to figure out the plot line. I see. No problem. Enjoy the show.

gentlefury · 11-22-2006, 10:55 AM

Quote:

IOW, you don't have any theories of your own, so it's easier to go around carping about others who are having a good time trying to figure out the plot line. I see. No problem. Enjoy the show.

[/b]

Never said I have no theories.....but i also try to read the posts to see what has already been said.....if something has been said already I will comment in that thread (which will in turn bring it to the top of the new posts board and grant it new life) rather than starting a new thread that was already started a while back....or earlier that day as seems to happen regularly as well....I have no problem with people coming up with original theories...what annoys me is that people keep bringing up the same ones over and over and over without regard for the fact that its already been discussed a while ago.

Speculate all you want and come up with as many original ideas as you can...thats the point of a discussion forum....but don't get all offended when someone calls you out for pointing out something that has already been pointed out ad nauseam. All I'm saying is...use the search bar at the top, and save yourself some grief....or grow a backbone....the internet can be a vial and wicked place.....this forum however is one of the tamest I've seen!

Guest · 11-23-2006, 05:32 PM

Quote:

I can't wait till that silly theory is put to rest.......course who knows....people will still find a way to justify it....hell, we have clearly seen Sylar's face and people are STILL saying he is freakin Peter!
[/b]

I know, I mean yes there is a slim chance for these rumors to be true, but to read it 50 times in 50 new topics is so annoying!. We should have an offical section for rumors that have been said many many times.

Just look at the facts, if it was 13-14 years ago then the Eden who meets Matt in "Six Months Ago" should be like 14 (based on how old Eden looks). But she just looks the same with a longer hair cut. And besides the epsiode is called SIX MONTHS AGO! which means the Matt storyline happening 13-14 years ago is totally unbelievable. Unless the writers did it to confuse us. hahaha

Also if what the post about the actor saying Peter and Matt meeting eachother is true, then that just adds to the "proof" that the theory is wrong. Unless Peter goes back in time or meets a 50 year old Matt in the present.

I seriously can't wait for the telepathic talking, will be funny.

Sorry I don't like to bash on people's theorys, I like respecting them, but too many topics on them.

11-23-2006, 07:01 PM

This theory is OBVIOUS, but so half hearted...

You see, the girl in the closet (this makes sense in a minute) IS Claire, but first Hiro helps take her back into the past for adoption. THEN Claire thinks Peter is so cool she wants to be JUST LIKE HIM, so Hiro takes her BACK AGAIN with a mind nubby from her dad. Calire gets a sexy change and becomes PETER. Then. Peter becomes despondent from the sexual confusion and asks Hiro to send him back in time again where he is hijacked under the knife by a mad genius (Mohinder's Dad) and transformed into Sylar. That's when this series starts.

I know, I know. No thanks necessary.

11-26-2006, 07:27 PM

Where to begin......

Unless the main plot thread is set in the future your theory of Clair being the little girl is wrong, I believe anyway.

Why? Matts cell phone is a motorola razer, a phone relesed to the unwashed masses of consumers less then 3 years ago. There are other things as well but this one'll do for me.

Not bad for a first post. Catch you later Bill & Ted.

11-27-2006, 10:10 AM

Quote:

I can't wait till that silly theory is put to rest.......course who knows....people will still find a way to justify it....hell, we have clearly seen Sylar's face and people are STILL saying he is freakin Peter!
[/b]

It's definitely more than Laid to rest. There is an interview on Youtube (not sure where it was originally from) where Matt is interviewed and he specifically talks about...

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

The link to that youtube interview was posted on this site an episode or two ago, Im sure you could do a search for Youtube and find it.

EDIT: And by "You" I mean anyone who still believes this timeline theory.

11-27-2006, 10:18 AM

Quote:

This theory is OBVIOUS, but so half hearted...

You see, the girl in the closet (this makes sense in a minute) IS Claire, but first Hiro helps take her back into the past for adoption. THEN Claire thinks Peter is so cool she wants to be JUST LIKE HIM, so Hiro takes her BACK AGAIN with a mind nubby from her dad. Calire gets a sexy change and becomes PETER. Then. Peter becomes despondent from the sexual confusion and asks Hiro to send him back in time again where he is hijacked under the knife by a mad genius (Mohinder's Dad) and transformed into Sylar. That's when this series starts.

I know, I know. No thanks necessary.
[/b]

You need professional help...lol :P

11-28-2006, 08:14 AM

OK, so the "major plot twist" theory has been laid to rest.

THANKS for those who provided intelligent feedback. We can close this thread now.

11-28-2006, 08:56 AM

Well, this 12-13 years ago stuff is a nice idea, but obviously doesn't work.

What works though is the idea that Mr. Bennet is part of the government. He knew something from the beginning. Perhaps his job was to protect that kid (Claire) for some reason, fell in love with her, pulled the Haitian guy on his side and quit his job and went rogue, using his knowledge and loyal people to remain hidden. In order to do so he's watching every potential threat closely.

The idea is still far fetched, but it seems like a possible motive and right direction. He's also clearly interested in Suresh's work (both of them), remember how Eden was trying to push Mohinder not to leave? She's wasn't really trying though. One the one hand, Mr. Bennet is interested in his work, on the other hand he might be afraid that he may find something out that's potentially dangerous for Claire.

This is all way too exciting.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

11-23-2006, 07:01 PM	#25
LostKids Posts: n/a	This theory is OBVIOUS, but so half hearted... You see, the girl in the closet (this makes sense in a minute) IS Claire, but first Hiro helps take her back into the past for adoption. THEN Claire thinks Peter is so cool she wants to be JUST LIKE HIM, so Hiro takes her BACK AGAIN with a mind nubby from her dad. Calire gets a sexy change and becomes PETER. Then. Peter becomes despondent from the sexual confusion and asks Hiro to send him back in time again where he is hijacked under the knife by a mad genius (Mohinder's Dad) and transformed into Sylar. That's when this series starts. I know, I know. No thanks necessary.

11-26-2006, 07:27 PM	#26
The Crimson Foot!! Posts: n/a	Where to begin...... Unless the main plot thread is set in the future your theory of Clair being the little girl is wrong, I believe anyway. Why? Matts cell phone is a motorola razer, a phone relesed to the unwashed masses of consumers less then 3 years ago. There are other things as well but this one'll do for me. Not bad for a first post. Catch you later Bill & Ted.

11-28-2006, 08:14 AM	#29
CharlieJ Posts: n/a	OK, so the "major plot twist" theory has been laid to rest. THANKS for those who provided intelligent feedback. We can close this thread now.

11-28-2006, 08:56 AM	#30
chtephan Posts: n/a	Well, this 12-13 years ago stuff is a nice idea, but obviously doesn't work. What works though is the idea that Mr. Bennet is part of the government. He knew something from the beginning. Perhaps his job was to protect that kid (Claire) for some reason, fell in love with her, pulled the Haitian guy on his side and quit his job and went rogue, using his knowledge and loyal people to remain hidden. In order to do so he's watching every potential threat closely. The idea is still far fetched, but it seems like a possible motive and right direction. He's also clearly interested in Suresh's work (both of them), remember how Eden was trying to push Mohinder not to leave? She's wasn't really trying though. One the one hand, Mr. Bennet is interested in his work, on the other hand he might be afraid that he may find something out that's potentially dangerous for Claire. This is all way too exciting.