Sylar = Cheerleader's Dad

Sylar (not HRG) is the Cheerleader's biological dad. Why else would the Horn-Rimmed Glasses Man hire two actors to pretend to be her parents? That means the Horn-Rimmed Glasses Man is a good guy. He is trying to protect his baby girl! Instead of letting his daughter find out her dad (Sylar) is a murderer, he hired two actors to protect her from the truth!!!!

What I'm trying to say is...
Horn-Rimmed Glasses Man = dad
Sylar = biological dad

If he was a murderer and Sylar...

Can you explain he didn't took Matt's or Nathan's brain?

Why he needed a gun to point at Nathan, and hesitated and decided not to shoot?

If you have the power of telekineses, you don't need a gun at all.


Sylar isn't Mr. B.

Good thinking though, but like 1 million people have said this. But dont think to much about the facts that has happened

DUDE! You read my post all wrong! Reread it! I reworded it to lessen the confusion!

DUDE! You read my post all wrong! Reread it! I reworded it to lessen the confusion!
[/b]

My apoligies

I did read it wrong, sorry lol


Well yeah good thinking... who knows... haven't thought about that really

Sylar (not HRG) is the Cheerleader's biological dad. Why else would the Horn-Rimmed Glasses Man hire two actors to pretend to be her parents? That means the Horn-Rimmed Glasses Man is a good guy. He is trying to protect his baby girl! Instead of letting his daughter find out her dad (Sylar) is a murderer, he hired two actors to protect her from the truth!!!!

What I'm trying to say is...
Horn-Rimmed Glasses Man = dad
Sylar = biological dad
[/b]

I dont think Sylar is her dad, the "actors" ( although I think they are not actors, rather people he works with ) were brought in cuz claire's biologicals were killed.

Either Killed OR Clare is an unwanted child that parents left and run off.

Also if Sylar is Claire's DAD then who's the mom? and what happened to her?

first post, so hey everyone.

been thinking about the mum thing, she seems far too ditsy to be with an 'agency' guy but shes the perfect cover for a boring everyday marriage. Glasses guy coulda got his mind eraser mate to rewrite her pre-series to set up the parents cover and let him study claire as she grew up. just a thought.

also with this Glasses guy, he hasn't actually hurt anyone that we know of, except the mind wipe on the rapist which to be fair was deserved and needed to protect his 'daughter'. so is he a baddy prepping sleeper agents, a goody trying to stop sylar or just a guy studying the heroes he can catch? guess we'll have a clue when he meets Isaac.

on the whole, who is sylar thing. tho i'm kinda leaning towards a future peter theory; nabbed hiros' time travel power, goes back in time for reasons yet unknown, maybe to meet papa suresh, who mistakenly helps him realise, that not only can he mirror powers temporarily when around other heroes, but if he eats/absorbs their brains then he has their powers permanently. then brain sucking addiction kicks in etc etc.

finally, tho kinda contradicting what i just wrote, the gun hiro finds next to future brain-jacked isaac in episode 2 seems to be the exact same gun that Glasses guy is pointing at nathan in episode 5. so either sylar's nicked his gun off him at some point, or Glasses guy is investigating sylar too and left it behind for some reason.

just some ideas....

Guys, I'm so sorry I have to repost this, but what needs to be done needs to be done (I really hate it when people create theories without thinking them through).

Don't you understand? Peter can not be the bad guy! If he was the bad guy, why would Hiro go back in time to talk to him? If Peter was the bad guy, Hiro would have went back in time to talk to a different main character! DUH! It's common sense! If Peter was the bad guy, don't you think Future Hiro would have went back in time to kill Peter (before he would be able to get other superpowers) instead of talk to him? And if you try to counter me by saying maby Future Hiro didn't know, then wouldn't you think when Future-Future Hiro (Hiro even futher into the future) found out, he would go back in time and stop Future Hiro from talking to Peter, and then commence to get rid of Peter? But maybe you could counter by saying maybe Future-Future Hiro never has a chance to go back in time and warn Future Hiro because Future-Future Hiro is killed by Peter right when he finds out Peter is a bad guy. BUT I doubt that is the case because that would make the show lose 50% of its viewers (too complicated story = bad story).

It's a tv show for God's sake. NBC is trying to appeal to as many people as possible! And to do this, NBC has to create a creative and simple, yet compelling, plot-driven tv show that will appeal to the young and old. That's what the entertainment business is all about!

And if Heroes went into the direction you are implying, things would just get to complicated and confusing. There's already too many plotholes as is! Plus - twist endings are only good for so long; they soon begin to wear thin!

PS. http://www.heroestheseries.com/who-is-the-...rvillain-sylar/

I dont think Sylar is her dad, the "actors" ( although I think they are not actors, rather people he works with ) were brought in cuz claire's biologicals were killed.
[/b]

What you said doesn't even make sense. Just because I said actors doesn't mean that those two actors couldn't have already been working for Mr. Bennet. When people pretend to be people they are not, they are acting (trust me, thats the definition). So when I said Mr. Bennet hired actors, he actually did HIRE ACTORS, regardless if the actors know Mr. Bennet personally or not. (If I hired my best friend to pretend to be my little brother, that would mean I hired him to act).

Thank you and good night.

Welcome to H-F Dakk209, We are digressing here this thread is supposed to be anout Claire's Bio dad is the Evil Sylar (cap guy).
> Mod

what If the 2 were Secert Agents then they are NOT hired Actors but Imposters. :P