episode "Five Years Gone" Season 1 ??????

oj777 · 11-07-2007, 04:33 PM

Its very late to bring this up, especially when everyone is into the 2nd season. I watched the episode "Five Years Gone" from season 1 the other day and there's 1 major thing I don't understand about the episode.

In the beginning of the episode future Hiro and Hiro from the past collide. At that time future Hiro explains to Hiro from the past that he attempted to kill Sylar by stabbing him however, Sylar didn't die because he regenerated. He regenerated because he KILLED THE CHEERLEADER and took her powers. However later in that episode we find out that the Cheerleader is still alive IN THE FUTURE; however, Sylar disguised as Nathan kills her at the end of the episode. This is a conflict b/c when future Hiro tries to kill Sylar, apparently the Cheerleader should have been still alive and with the Cheerleader alive Sylar couldn't have regenerated meaning that Sylar should be dead.

Anybody care to explain??????????

crimsontide · 11-07-2007, 07:47 PM

hi mate

remember that the future Hiro stabbed Syler but he regenerated. So he went back in Time and told Peter to save Claire - which he did. Now a different Future is formed Syler cannot regenerate. However in this different futre Hiro went into the future by mistake. So he missed the bomb and he did not stab Syler. So the world still ended up in a mess.
I hope that answered your question
On that note. You cant go into the future and see a future self because you would be missing for that amount of time how ever you can see your past self.

11-07-2007, 04:33 PM	#1
oj777 Junior Member Join Date: Nov 2007 Posts: 2	episode "Five Years Gone" Season 1 ?????? Its very late to bring this up, especially when everyone is into the 2nd season. I watched the episode "Five Years Gone" from season 1 the other day and there's 1 major thing I don't understand about the episode. In the beginning of the episode future Hiro and Hiro from the past collide. At that time future Hiro explains to Hiro from the past that he attempted to kill Sylar by stabbing him however, Sylar didn't die because he regenerated. He regenerated because he KILLED THE CHEERLEADER and took her powers. However later in that episode we find out that the Cheerleader is still alive IN THE FUTURE; however, Sylar disguised as Nathan kills her at the end of the episode. This is a conflict b/c when future Hiro tries to kill Sylar, apparently the Cheerleader should have been still alive and with the Cheerleader alive Sylar couldn't have regenerated meaning that Sylar should be dead. Anybody care to explain??????????

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

11-07-2007, 07:47 PM	#2
crimsontide Junior Member Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: North East England Posts: 21	hi mate remember that the future Hiro stabbed Syler but he regenerated. So he went back in Time and told Peter to save Claire - which he did. Now a different Future is formed Syler cannot regenerate. However in this different futre Hiro went into the future by mistake. So he missed the bomb and he did not stab Syler. So the world still ended up in a mess. I hope that answered your question On that note. You cant go into the future and see a future self because you would be missing for that amount of time how ever you can see your past self.