American Idol 7: Top 6 Performance Rankings - Page 2

randomx6 · 04-23-2008, 04:53 AM

Extremely unfair since Syesha is an actress but AI doesn't seem to care what they do to their cattle oops performers.

Brooke and Jason were completely not supposed to sing this stuff so I give them a pass. Archie on the other hand WAS AWFUL. Another slow weepy boring as hell ballad and he stil stunk it up. Go home kid.

1. David C
2. Syesha
3 Carly

chasm

Brooke
Jason

big hole
David A

MattGoodwin · 04-23-2008, 04:53 AM

Yuor rankings are perfect, except switch David A and Brooke. Archie hurt my ears tonight. But regardless of what he does up there he is safe. But, it was a complete mess. Brooke will probably go home unfortunately. All 5 of them are more talented than David Archuleta. It is BS

carjean · 04-23-2008, 05:22 AM

Re Brooke and Jason being at a disadvantage because of theme choice. They both had tons of choices that would suit their styles.Maybe they don't have time to really look at the choices. The reason they can't do theme weeks( ditch the themes!) in my opinion is because they aren't that great of singer/performers.They are both charming. Either one of them would be a shoe-in to win Canadian Idol. We like charming and quirky, but they are a little too one dimensional for AI.

b0001882 · 04-23-2008, 05:25 AM

I agree with ArmanValder2 completely - I wish Michael Johns and Kristy Lee Cook had been here this week. Michael especially would have done something memorable with this theme, and Kristy Lee was always able to rise to the occasion. Both would have been far, far better than Brooke and Jason, who should BOTH go home after last night's debacles.

actor333kirby333 · 04-23-2008, 05:31 AM

YAYYYY!!!!!!!!! GO SYESHA!!!!!!!!!! She was awesome last night and i was afraid she would go home but i have a feeling she's gonna stick around a little longer. But for my FAIR rankings 1. David Cook 2. SYESHA 3. David A. 4. Carly 5. Jason 6. Brooke (i think if she didn't start over i would have her above jason but that was just CRAZY)

micodeavi · 04-23-2008, 06:10 AM

The best was David C, as usual. Syesha was amazing, gorgeous and entertaining, which made me an official Syesha fan! I actually kinda liked Brooke, and I appriciate her braveness to start all over again. I did not enjoy Castro AT ALL, but poor guy, I can see the pain in his face when singing.

JazzyJake · 04-23-2008, 07:02 AM

My rating agrees with Oscar and AIAddict, though I waver on who was worst. 3 good performances, who'da thunk it? (3 bad ones also)

I wish Syesha had done a better song, but she looked great and nailed it. It was nearly perfect for what it was.
Carly seemed to miss that her song was sung by Judas and he is angry and confused, but she was heavily criticised for sounding angry on a past performance, so maybe this is good for her.
DCook surprised me with the power he showed on that song, well done, but I enjoyed Carly's performance more.They couldn't all do songs from Superstar though it may have benefited Cook and Brooke.

I think Cheeseboy's performance was awkward and not very good, I've downgraded my initial thought.

I'll borrow AIAddict's adjective "inexcusable" for the performances of Jason and Brooke, bad vocals, bad song choices and bad performances; they stepped down while others stepped up.

JazzyJake · 04-23-2008, 07:25 AM

Oops, I was wrong, I have Carly at #2 and Syesha at #3.

I disagree with you Oscar regarding Brooke's song options. I thought Everything's All Right from Superstar would have been perfect for her. Another Suitcase, Another Hall from Evita may have worked also.

KevinCheng2 · 04-23-2008, 07:26 AM

My Personal Rankings:
1. Carly Smithson
2. Syesha Mercado
3. David Cook
4. David Archuleta
5. Brooke White
6. Jason Castro

sylcook2 · 04-23-2008, 07:44 AM

The best was DC, I'm agree with you in the top 3, but in the bottom three I think Jason is before Archuleta, I don't know what happen to Archie but his performance was so boring yesterday.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

04-23-2008, 04:53 AM	#11
randomx6 Junior Member Join Date: Mar 2008 Posts: 109	Extremely unfair since Syesha is an actress but AI doesn't seem to care what they do to their cattle oops performers. Brooke and Jason were completely not supposed to sing this stuff so I give them a pass. Archie on the other hand WAS AWFUL. Another slow weepy boring as hell ballad and he stil stunk it up. Go home kid. 1. David C 2. Syesha 3 Carly chasm Brooke Jason big hole David A

04-23-2008, 04:53 AM	#12
MattGoodwin Junior Member Join Date: Apr 2007 Posts: 105	Yuor rankings are perfect, except switch David A and Brooke. Archie hurt my ears tonight. But regardless of what he does up there he is safe. But, it was a complete mess. Brooke will probably go home unfortunately. All 5 of them are more talented than David Archuleta. It is BS

04-23-2008, 05:22 AM	#13
carjean Junior Member Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 55	Re Brooke and Jason being at a disadvantage because of theme choice. They both had tons of choices that would suit their styles.Maybe they don't have time to really look at the choices. The reason they can't do theme weeks( ditch the themes!) in my opinion is because they aren't that great of singer/performers.They are both charming. Either one of them would be a shoe-in to win Canadian Idol. We like charming and quirky, but they are a little too one dimensional for AI.

04-23-2008, 05:25 AM	#14
b0001882 Junior Member Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 49	I agree with ArmanValder2 completely - I wish Michael Johns and Kristy Lee Cook had been here this week. Michael especially would have done something memorable with this theme, and Kristy Lee was always able to rise to the occasion. Both would have been far, far better than Brooke and Jason, who should BOTH go home after last night's debacles.

04-23-2008, 05:31 AM	#15
actor333kirby333 Junior Member Join Date: Jun 2007 Posts: 27	YAYYYY!!!!!!!!! GO SYESHA!!!!!!!!!! She was awesome last night and i was afraid she would go home but i have a feeling she's gonna stick around a little longer. But for my FAIR rankings 1. David Cook 2. SYESHA 3. David A. 4. Carly 5. Jason 6. Brooke (i think if she didn't start over i would have her above jason but that was just CRAZY)

04-23-2008, 06:10 AM	#16
micodeavi Junior Member Join Date: Apr 2008 Posts: 1	The best was David C, as usual. Syesha was amazing, gorgeous and entertaining, which made me an official Syesha fan! I actually kinda liked Brooke, and I appriciate her braveness to start all over again. I did not enjoy Castro AT ALL, but poor guy, I can see the pain in his face when singing.

04-23-2008, 07:02 AM	#17
JazzyJake Junior Member Join Date: Jan 2008 Posts: 233	My rating agrees with Oscar and AIAddict, though I waver on who was worst. 3 good performances, who'da thunk it? (3 bad ones also) I wish Syesha had done a better song, but she looked great and nailed it. It was nearly perfect for what it was. Carly seemed to miss that her song was sung by Judas and he is angry and confused, but she was heavily criticised for sounding angry on a past performance, so maybe this is good for her. DCook surprised me with the power he showed on that song, well done, but I enjoyed Carly's performance more.They couldn't all do songs from Superstar though it may have benefited Cook and Brooke. I think Cheeseboy's performance was awkward and not very good, I've downgraded my initial thought. I'll borrow AIAddict's adjective "inexcusable" for the performances of Jason and Brooke, bad vocals, bad song choices and bad performances; they stepped down while others stepped up.

04-23-2008, 07:25 AM	#18
JazzyJake Junior Member Join Date: Jan 2008 Posts: 233	Oops, I was wrong, I have Carly at #2 and Syesha at #3. I disagree with you Oscar regarding Brooke's song options. I thought Everything's All Right from Superstar would have been perfect for her. Another Suitcase, Another Hall from Evita may have worked also.

04-23-2008, 07:26 AM	#19
KevinCheng2 Junior Member Join Date: Apr 2008 Posts: 5	My Personal Rankings: 1. Carly Smithson 2. Syesha Mercado 3. David Cook 4. David Archuleta 5. Brooke White 6. Jason Castro

04-23-2008, 07:44 AM	#20
sylcook2 Junior Member Join Date: Apr 2008 Posts: 40	The best was DC, I'm agree with you in the top 3, but in the bottom three I think Jason is before Archuleta, I don't know what happen to Archie but his performance was so boring yesterday.