American Idol 7: Top 7 Results Show Recap - Page 3

jazzyjaime2 · 04-18-2008, 08:19 AM

i half agree with the bottom 3 kristy needed to go home tired of her whining voice carly should have been in the bottom 3 with jason castro he is so so so horrible should have gone weeks ago and does Americans really feel he was better than Hernandez and johns so what brooke messed up on the piano who is perfect in this world not even mariah with her lip singing to all but 1 minute of the song david a forgot lyrics to a song and brooke ends up in the bottom 3 for hitting the wrong note on the piano now we really know this is a popularity contest he is young , smiley, but really the get has no moves but a hand twirl get for real he is not ready for the big world in music maybe he should start out singing jingles for commercials david cook rocks he has been so emotional the last 2 shows though but here is my top 3 in the finale week david cook, brooke white and syesha mercardo (maybe) if not carly by the grace of god will be on that stage lets hope not though but it will more than likel

kash3737 · 04-18-2008, 09:47 AM

i think people finally are realizing that Carly actually can be great if the judges stop stripping her of her confidence, hopefully this will boost her up and she will get back to where she was when she started out. As for next week Brooke should go. I do not understand why there are so many David Cook haters. The guy is talented and is a true artist. You do not have to like is pop rock style. But to say he does not deserve to be top 3 is too much. Stop eating up what the judges tell you and really listen to David A. he is great vocally, but needs to take it to the next level before you all anoint him the winner. I think its still a wide open competition. Not like last year where we knew the top two by now.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

04-18-2008, 08:19 AM	#21
jazzyjaime2 Junior Member Join Date: Mar 2008 Posts: 30	i half agree with the bottom 3 kristy needed to go home tired of her whining voice carly should have been in the bottom 3 with jason castro he is so so so horrible should have gone weeks ago and does Americans really feel he was better than Hernandez and johns so what brooke messed up on the piano who is perfect in this world not even mariah with her lip singing to all but 1 minute of the song david a forgot lyrics to a song and brooke ends up in the bottom 3 for hitting the wrong note on the piano now we really know this is a popularity contest he is young , smiley, but really the get has no moves but a hand twirl get for real he is not ready for the big world in music maybe he should start out singing jingles for commercials david cook rocks he has been so emotional the last 2 shows though but here is my top 3 in the finale week david cook, brooke white and syesha mercardo (maybe) if not carly by the grace of god will be on that stage lets hope not though but it will more than likel

04-18-2008, 09:47 AM	#22
kash3737 Junior Member Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 61	i think people finally are realizing that Carly actually can be great if the judges stop stripping her of her confidence, hopefully this will boost her up and she will get back to where she was when she started out. As for next week Brooke should go. I do not understand why there are so many David Cook haters. The guy is talented and is a true artist. You do not have to like is pop rock style. But to say he does not deserve to be top 3 is too much. Stop eating up what the judges tell you and really listen to David A. he is great vocally, but needs to take it to the next level before you all anoint him the winner. I think its still a wide open competition. Not like last year where we knew the top two by now.